AI Doesn’t Replace the Human Touch...It Amplifies It

What if AI didn’t replace the human touch in gym sales - but actually made it possible more often? In this new article, Jeff Pressly, Director of Sales for North America at Keepme, breaks down why AI-powered sales agents aren’t making things less personal they're actually delivering more opportunities to engage face to face.
Jeff Pressly
Jeff Pressly
September 9th, 2025
AI Doesn’t Replace the Human Touch...It Amplifies It

We’re a people business.

If you’re a fitness operator, you’ve likely said this. It’s the most common reason I hear when clubs hesitate to bring AI into a customer-facing role. And I get it. You’re proud of your team. You care about the personal experience and you firmly believe in the power of human connection to build trust and convert members.

But here’s the tough truth: the human touch that so many operators value is rarely delivered when it matters most.

Our CEO, Ian Mullane, put it best: “It’s not AI that risks damaging the member experience...it’s the gaps in your current process.”

Let’s dig into what that actually means for your sales team, your prospects, and your business.

Human Teams Can’t Operate at the Speed of Intent

When someone enquires about your gym, they’re at a moment of intent. But intent fades fast.

  • 78% of buyers go with the first company to respond

  • 82% expect a reply within 10 minutes

  • Over 50% of all gym searches happen after hours

  • And yet… 58% of email enquiries in North America go unanswered

We’ve seen it time and again: prospects reach out at 10pm, get no reply, and by the time your team follows up the next day, they’ve ghosted you. You didn’t lose that sale because your team wasn’t friendly, you lost it because you weren’t there. You team has to sleep, right?

AI doesn’t compete with your salespeople. It fills in where they physically can’t. It responds instantly across a variety of channels, even inbound and outbound calls. It’s not there to steal the conversation. It’s there to make sure the conversation happens that will get them through your doors...where the important human interaction take place.

Your Salespeople Didn’t Sign Up to Be Admin Robots

Let’s be honest: no one got into fitness sales because they love chasing leads that have gone cold or typing the same answers 25 times a day. Your team thrives when they’re in their element - meeting people face to face, showing them around the club, connecting over goals and helping them imagine a better version of themselves.

AI doesn’t take that away. It makes it possible more often.

By removing the repetitive admin - chasing unresponsive leads, sending calendar invites, answering “what are your hours?” for the hundredth time - AI lets your team show up where they’re needed most: in the club, energized, focused, and ready to close.

It doesn’t dilute the human experience. It amplifies it.

AI Enables More Human Moments, Not Fewer

When Antares is deployed, we see a consistent pattern:

  • Calendars fill with high-intent bookings

  • Fewer no-shows (because Antares keeps them warm)

  • Better tour-to-sale ratios (because the right people show up)

  • More human energy in every interaction (because your team isn’t burned out chasing ghosts)

AI That Gets Better Every Quarter

Unlike traditional tools, AI agents don’t get tired of the grind or plateau in performance. Every few months, the models improve, sharper reasoning, more contextual memory, better nuance in conversations, and those improvements automatically make your AI agents smarter, faster, and more effective.

That means:

  • The longer you use it, the greater your edge

  • Your AI doesn’t just maintain performance - it compounds it

  • Competitors who delay adoption won’t just start later — they’ll start from behind

If your AI has been in-market for 3, 6, or 12 months, it’s not the same product it was on day one. It’s smarter. More experienced. More aligned to your prospects’ language, objections, and preferences. That’s an unfair advantage that stacks up fast.

The Real Role of AI in Fitness Sales

Let’s call it like it is: the point of AI in your sales process isn’t to mimic people. It’s to get more people in front of your team.

AI doesn’t smile during a gym tour. It doesn’t build rapport in person. It doesn’t shake hands or high-five a new member after their first class.

What it does do is ensure those moments actually happen, and happen more often, by working 24/7 to qualify leads, book tours, answer questions, and keep your gym's sales pipeline warm.

What We’re Hearing from Gym Teams on the Ground

Sales professionals working alongside Keepme Antares are telling us:

I’m not wasting time anymore. I’m spending my energy with real prospects - people who want to be here.

Our no-shows are pretty much non-existent. We’re busier with the right people.

That’s the magic. That’s the point.

In just three months Antares has had almost 60,000 conversations and about 450 tours booked out of hours. It's been a massive assistance to all MCs...we've got more leads and we're walking into more appointments. It's a no-brainer! Who wouldn't want that?

Amy Schafer
National Sales Manager - Fitness Cartel

It’s Time to Rethink What ‘Human Touch’ Really Means

If you’re still hesitant about using AI in your sales funnel, ask yourself this:

Is the ‘human touch’ a principle you’re committed to… or just a promise your team can’t deliver consistently?

Because with AI:

  • Every enquiry gets a reply

  • Every prospect gets nurtured

  • Every sales rep gets back time to do what they love

  • Every club gets the chance to deliver better human interactions, not fewer

This isn’t the end of human connection in fitness sales. It’s the start of doing it better.

👉 Ready to see how AI can fill your calendar and free your team? Book your self-drive demo of Keepme Antares now