Mystery shop benchmark for gym sales and marketing leaders

The Great No-Show Opportunity

What 248 mystery shopped booking journeys reveal about gym no-shows.

Booking a tour is only half the job. We mystery shopped 248 booking journeys across 75 North American brands to see how gyms handle reminders, and what happens after a prospect fails to show.

248 journeys shopped
75 brands studied
6,500 locations
37 page report
Trusted by North American fitness operators
logo-club4.pnglogo-exercise-coach.pnglogo-chicago.pnglogo-active-wellness.pnglogo-cedardale.pnglogo-genesis.pnglogo-everlast.png

What You Will Find Inside

Benchmark data and ready-made flows built from real booking journeys.

Are tours and trials offered?

Whether brands offer a tour or trial at all, and how many use a structured calendar slot rather than an open trial.

Booking experiences compared

How 248 North American booking journeys compare on calendar booking, confirmations and the friction prospects face.

Pre-tour reminders in practice

What reminders prospects actually receive after booking, split by channel, and how many journeys received none at all.

What happens after a no-show

How operators follow up, rebook or abandon prospects after a missed tour or trial, and how personal that outreach feels.

Why manual follow-up fails

Why teams struggle to sustain consistent reminders and follow-ups, and how AI-powered automation helps.

Ready-made communication flows

What a strong tour reminder, post-tour and no-show flow looks like, so you can build or improve your own sequences.

What The Study Found

Findings from 248 North American booking journeys, drawn from the report.

39.47%
Of operators send no reminder after a tour or trial is booked
55.35%
Of pre-booked tour or trial journeys sent no reminders
14.47%
Of operators do not follow up at all after a no-show
20.13%
Of operators offer no way to rebook a prospect after a no-show
33.87%
Of gyms offer trials with no scheduled date or time
98%
SMS open rate, against 26.8% for email, quoted in the report

What Operators Say

It’s been exciting to see ‘Vicky’ embody who we are as a brand and represent us so naturally. It’s gratifying to watch how seamlessly Antares communicates availability and schedules tours in a way that reflects our standards.

Brad Bundy
Brad Bundy
COO - The Exercise Coach

We've seen a significant impact from after hours engagement. Antares is contacting inquiries immediately, and it's already driven nearly 300 extra tours this month. It gives us the speed, consistency, and 24/7 customer service we couldn't provide with staffing alone.

Stephen Trapani
Stephen Trapani
VP - Club4 Fitness
Download the report